As his successor’s confirmation nears, Attorney General Eric Holder has been on a farewell tour?giving exit interviews, penning editorials, and preparing for his last day at the Department of Justice, which is unveiling a commemorative portrait of him on Friday. In one interview, Politico?s Mike Allen pressed him about the ongoing Ferguson investigation. Holder dodged, but did say he wants to give ?serious consideration? to adjusting the legal bar for investigating cases of police brutality?specifically, the level of intent required to prosecute civil-rights crimes.

?I think that if we adjust those standards, we can make the federal government a better backstop?make us more a part of the process in an appropriate way to reassure the American people that decisions are made by people who are really disinterested,? Holder said. ?I think that if we make those adjustments, we will have that capacity.?

Holder didn?t specify the nature of the adjustments, but there?s a lot to unpack in that statement. The ?better backstop? is a reference to the seeming failure of DOJ to prosecute notable incidents of police violence against minorities, particularly cases where state prosecutions have been called into question. On Tuesday, the department announced it found ?insufficient evidence? to federally prosecute George Zimmerman, the Florida man acquitted in state court for the killing of Trayvon Martin. And with an announcement on Ferguson looming?Holder told Politico he plans to make it before he leaves office?there?s no guarantee DOJ will be prosecuting officer Darren Wilson, either.

So how can DOJ be better at these cases? The only way is with a legislative fix, and that?s where Holder is bound to run into issues. For one, it?s no secret that Congress is not fond of him. As of October, he and the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee were still engaged in a court battle over the non-disclosure of documents in connection with DOJ?s handling of the Operation Fast and Furious. That case stemmed from a separate standoff where Congress voted to hold Holder in contempt?the first time the measure was deployed against a sitting Cabinet member.

But even if Congress ignored this political baggage, Holder would still have to convince lawmakers that lowering the bar for civil-rights offenses is a good idea. And here the arguments turn on both policy and politics. The policy argument is constitutional: Every defendant has a right to due process under the law?even those accused of the most heinous, racially motivated killings. Currently, federal civil-rights laws require those defendants to act ?willfully? before they can be found guilty. It?s an extremely high bar that yields mixed results: It was famously met when a federal grand jury indicted four officers for the 1991 beating of Rodney King; the case even made a trip to the Supreme Court. But it has proven ineffective in more recent incidents, including the Zimmerman case.

Here lawmakers would face a tough choice. A high bar for civil-rights prosecutions ensures that only the most egregious cases of official misconduct and civilian intolerance receive federal scrutiny. The government punishes truly racist forms of violence?as well as offenses predicated on a bias against the victim’s religion, disability, or sexual orientation. Lowering the bar would not only break with that tradition, but changing the ?willful? requirement to include, say, merely ?knowing? or ?reckless? behavior runs the risk of sweeping too broadly. It could open up more mundane forms of assault to federal prosecution?cases that may appear racially motivated, but that in reality turned out to be someone doing something stupid or acting in self-defense. A drunken brawl that leads to death could be viewed as reckless. If you throw race in the mix, does the killing automatically become racially motivated?

To be sure, all physical violence should be proscribed, but some kinds, like the drunken brawl, are best reserved for state and local authorities to investigate. As it is, the federal government already has far too many laws on the books at its disposal with lax or no intent requirement, and federal prosecutions can be overzealous. Just this week, Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan complained of ?overcriminalization and excessive punishment? in federal law.

Holder’s quote raises a sensitive political issue, too. At present, DOJ relies on separate statutes to investigate civil-rights crimes?one that covers private persons (the Martin-Zimmerman case), and one that covers public servants (Michael Brown-Darren Wilson). Will Holder propose to lower the bar for all these laws across the board, or only for one group and not the other? Law enforcement’s staunchest supporters would oppose legislation making it easier for violent police officers to go to prison, and law enforcement’s staunchest critics wouldn’t accept lower the bar for private citizens only. If the Ferguson aftermath has taught us anything, it?s that Americans are divided on whether cops deserve the benefit of the doubt or should be held accountable to the fullest extent of the law.

Whatever Holder decides, he?s confident he?s done his part. ?I don?t think anybody would be able to look at this Justice Department over the last six years,“ he told Politico, „and say that we?ve been anything other than aggressive in trying to root out inappropriate police conduct while, at the same time, trying to establish?or reestablish?bonds of trust between communities of color and people in law enforcement.?

Cristian Farias is a journalist and lawyer who writes on civil rights, criminal justice, and the courts. You can follow him on Twitter.

More on this topic More celebrity news

Bulgarian regulators to target Uber drivers ? reports

февруари 28, 2015

Several Bulgarian state institutions, including transport and competition regulators, but also the country?s National Revenue Agency (NRA), were preparing checks into the operations of taxi and car-sharing services firm Uber in the country?s capital city Sofia, according to reports in Bulgarian media. Mass circulation daily Trud quoted Tsvetlin Tsvetanov, head of the car administration agency […]

прочети →

Lithuania?s LITGAS Signs Non-binding MoU with Delfin for US LNG

февруари 28, 2015

February 27th, 2015 4:55pm Posted In: Recent News, News By Country, More Countries, Lithuania, United States, Baltic Focus After the recent visit of Lithuania?s Energy Minister Rokas Masiulis to the United States, LITGAS signed a non-binding Memorandum of Understanding with Delfin LNG for gas supplies from the first offshore floating liquefaction project in the US […]

прочети →

What Muslim extremists have taught me

февруари 28, 2015

USA (MNN) ? The last few weeks have been kind of frustrating both professionally and personally. Professionally as I have covered terror in the world. Personally as I have be the target of attacks simply for being a Christian. Mission Network News continues to focus on what?s going on in the world as it relates […]

прочети →

Giant fish caught in Italy is a real monster

февруари 27, 2015

UPDATE (26-Feb 2015): Another one! Reel-y? 280-pound catfish reportedly caught in Italy?s Po River ? CNN.com. One thing that makes the latest Po River catch unique is that it was done with a spinning reel, said Valla, who called it a record for such fishing tackle. It took Ferrari 40 minutes to bring in the […]

прочети →

Conservatives Don’t Have an Obamacare Replacement Because They’re Too Busy Complaining About Obamacare

февруари 27, 2015

With the Supreme Court scheduled to hear the Obamacare challenge King vs. Burwell next week, Democrats and Republicans are both trying to influence the Court?s decision. For the left, that means focusing on the millions of people who could lose health insurance if the Court rules that the Affordable Care Act doesn’t provide subsidies in the […]

прочети →

Bosnia Maps 150 Wartime Detention Sites

февруари 27, 2015

Map of detention camps and sites. Photo: TJAR. The Association for Transitional Justice, Responsibility and Remembrance and the Centre for Democracy and Transitional Justice on Thursday presented the web database which has so far documented 150 places where around 30,000 people were detained and around 5,000 killed. Dzenana Karup-Drusko, president of the Association for Transitional […]

прочети →

Portugal to Come Up with LNG Strategy for Road Transportation by Year-end

февруари 27, 2015

February 26th, 2015 5:50pm Posted In: Recent News, LNG, News By Country, More Countries, Portugal The European Union will support Portugal in its plans to promote LNG in road transportation, selecting the project for EU funding under the the TEN-T Annual Call 2013. ?The EU’s TEN-T Programme will back with over ?150,000 the national policy […]

прочети →

UPI: Putin again employs natural gas as diplomatic weapon

февруари 26, 2015

February 25th, 2015 11:55pm Posted In: Press Notes Russia has returned to threats of curtailment of natural gas shipments to Ukraine, and European gas prices rose on the prospect this week. The Russian natural gas company Gazprom cited increased risks associated with shipping its product to Europe, and Tuesday suggested it would stop shipments to […]

прочети →

Democrats Target Climate-Deniers-for-Hire

февруари 26, 2015

Over the weekend, The New York Times and The Guardian reported that the fossil fuel industry paid astrophysicist Wei-Hock „Willie“ Soon $1.25 million in grants in exchange for 11 scientific papers that cast doubt on the role humans play in climate change. Soon never disclosed the grants from the Charles G. Koch Foundation, ExxonMobil, Southern Company, and […]

прочети →

The Failure of Macho Christianity

февруари 25, 2015

In an era of things coming undone?families from their traditional bonds, populations from their places of origin, genders from their longtime roles?the impulse to retreat into the lifestyles of steadier times is detectable in discourse and media, from our fascination with costume dramas to our encounters with ever more reactionary conservatisms. It?s within this tendency […]

прочети →

Eurozone agrees on four-month Greek bailout extension

февруари 25, 2015

Varoufakis, the Greek finance minister, spoke to the press after the Eurogroup meeting in Brussels on Friday After two collapsed Eurogroup meetings, acrimonious public exchanges and intense discussion, the eurozone finance ministers finally found an agreement for a four-month extension of the current financial rescue programme for Greece. The deal concluded on Friday night (February […]

прочети →

Serbia, EU Reach Agreement on Srbijagas

февруари 25, 2015

February 24th, 2015 8:34pm Posted In: Recent News, News By Country, Serbia, Balkans/SEE Focus The European Energy Community and the Serbian Ministry of Mining and Energy have agreed on an action plan for restructuring Srbijagas, lifting an obstacle to Serbia’s progress toward the EU in the energy sphere. Previously the European Energy Community announced that […]

прочети →
Страница 1 от 6312345...102030...Последна »